Skip to content
AN INDEPENDENT GUIDE TO THE GAME EXPLORE THE PLAYER DATABASE

THE TRAITORS: NEW BLOOD ✦ PLAYER INTELLIGENCE

EVERYONE HAS A SECRET.

Inside the castle, every alliance matters. Explore player profiles, episode timelines and live Traitor and Faithful statuses.

ProfilesEpisode timelinesGame developments

INSIDE THE CASTLE

Latest player profiles

Contestant biographies, game roles and verified episode developments.

Browse all players

Joe Vanella: Age, Funeral Director Career, Traitor Status & The Traitors: New Blood Episode 9 Update

반응형

Joe Vanella is a 44-year-old, fourth-generation funeral director from Wantagh, New York, and one of the original Traitors selected at the start of The Traitors: New Blood. He and Tomica Adams began the secret team, later recruiting Katie Fites. He also carried out the cursed-apple murder in plain sight that eliminated Niyyah Hayes—an action that brought Victor Vollbrechthausen’s Fruitgate suspicions dangerously close to the truth.

Joe remains an active Traitor after Episode 9 (November 5, 2026), working with Katie Fites following Tomica Adams’ banishment. The pair chose Morgan Cook for the poisoned-chalice murder rather than target Victor Vollbrechthausen, whose suspicions of Joe remain public. Morgan’s exit leaves 10 players: eight Faithfuls and two Traitors. No new banishment occurred in Episode 9.

Joe Vanella in his original The Traitors New Blood cast portrait
Joe Vanella in his existing
The Traitors: New Blood
cast portrait. Image credit: NBC/Peacock via the original published profile.
ACTIVE — TRAITOR

Live Game Status

Current role: Original Traitor. Status: Still competing after Episode 9.

Latest completed episode: Episode 9 — “Playing Chess” (November 5, 2026).

Active Traitor team: Joe Vanella and Katie Fites. Original teammate Tomica Adams was banished in Episode 8 and revealed to be a Traitor.

Episode 7: Joe and Katie opposed Tomica’s push to murder her vocal accuser Victor; the Traitors murdered Mark Zgoda. Victor then drew the most Round Table votes, but his elimination was held for the Power of the Pardon decision.

Episode 8: Shane Beatty pardoned Victor; the Traitors murdered Abby Lee. Joe acknowledged that Tomica might be a Traitor when challenged at the Round Table and joined the 10–2 vote to banish her.

Episode 9: Joe and Katie selected Morgan Cook for the poisoned chalice instead of Victor. At the toast, Joe and Shane Beatty made the only glass exchange; Morgan was confirmed murdered at breakfast. Victor continued suspecting Joe, and Abbey Benjamin also questioned Joe’s shifts around Tomica. There was no Round Table banishment.

Remaining cast: 10 contestants after Episode 9 — two Traitors and eight Faithfuls.

Spoiler warning: This profile includes verified events through Episode 9, including Joe’s original Traitor role, Katie Fites’ recruitment, Niyyah Hayes’ cursed-apple murder, Mark Zgoda and Abby Lee’s murders, Shane Beatty’s pardon of Victor, Tomica Adams’ Traitor reveal, Morgan Cook’s poisoned-chalice murder and the unresolved suspicions of Joe.

Episode-by-Episode Timeline

Episode 1 — Selected as an Original Traitor

Alan Cumming selected Joe Vanella and Tomica Adams as the original Traitors. The pair began making decisions away from the Faithfuls, chose Katie Fites and Xavier Scruggs as Accomplice candidates, and selected Kim Daily as their first murder victim.

Episode 2 — Watches the Accomplice Competition

As the Faithfuls reacted to Kim’s murder and Madeline Kostopulos’ banishment, Joe and Tomica continued evaluating Katie and Xavier for the third Traitor position. Joe kept his role hidden while taking part in the public conversations.

Episode 3 — Katie Joins the Traitor Team

Katie and Xavier both completed the Accomplice challenge. Joe and Tomica chose Katie to join them as the third Traitor, and Xavier was murdered. The decision expanded the team while leaving behind a possible line of suspicion because Xavier had previously raised questions about Katie.

Episode 4 — Arisa Is Banished

A clue connected to the Accomplice twist led the Faithfuls toward a mistaken theory involving Arisa Thomas and Victor Vollbrechthausen. Arisa received 13 votes and was revealed as a Faithful. Joe remained outside the main accusation.

After Episode 4 — Logan Smith Is Murdered

After Arisa’s banishment, Joe, Tomica and Katie chose Logan Smith as their next murder victim. Logan had kept Katie in mind after remembering Xavier’s earlier suspicions about her. Logan’s murder removed a player who was beginning to revisit that connection.

Episode 5 — Votes for Sherry and Attempts the Apple Murder

At the Round Table, Joe voted for Sherry Kuehl, who was banished with 11 votes and revealed herself as a Faithful. During the murder-in-plain-sight task, Joe tried to pass the cursed apple to Morgan Cook, but she did not catch it. He ate the apple himself to avoid drawing further attention, while Tomica’s later offers of fruit helped prompt Victor to begin questioning the sequence.

Episode 6 — Niyyah Hayes Is Murdered in Plain Sight

The previous episode’s cliffhanger was resolved when Niyyah Hayes was identified as the victim of the cursed-apple murder. Joe had successfully passed her the apple, which she caught. While they lay in the staged coffins, Joe told Niyyah that he was sorry and had sacrificed a Faithful. Niyyah was then confirmed to have been murdered.

Episode 6 — Victor’s Fruitgate Theory Identifies Joe and Tomica

Victor connected Joe’s behavior with the apple to Tomica’s decision to offer fruit to other contestants. He shared the theory with Morgan Cook and Mark Zgoda, then brought it to the Round Table. Tomica defended her actions, while Joe insisted there had been no apples in the fridge. The theory was correct, but most contestants did not follow it.

Episode 6 — Joe Votes for Wyatt as Michael Is Banished

Joe voted for Wyatt Gillespie. Michael Foote received eight votes, while Victor and Wyatt each received three and Tomica received one. Michael was banished and revealed himself as a Faithful. Joe survived without receiving a vote and remained an active Traitor with Tomica and Katie.

Episode 7 — The Traitors Murder Mark Zgoda

In the turret, Tomica Adams advocated killing Victor Vollbrechthausen, who had publicly accused her. Joe and Katie argued that murdering Victor could validate his theory. The team instead considered Mark, Wyatt and Kriste, and selected Mark Zgoda. Mark’s absence was revealed at breakfast.

Episode 7 — Fruitgate Persists as Victor Faces a Pardon

Victor continued pressing his suspicions of Joe and Tomica, while Joe’s name came up in the Round Table discussion of the apple murder. Victor received the most banishment votes (five), with Tomica receiving three, but the result was interrupted by the Power of the Pardon twist. Joe was not identified as a new banishment target in the published vote totals. The pardon decision was left unresolved until the next episode.

Episode 8 — Shane Saves Victor; Joe Pushes Back

Shane Beatty was revealed as the Power of the Pardon winner and spared Victor. Published recaps describe Joe as unhappy about the reversal. Tomica and Katie then addressed their previous conflict in the turret; Joe said he wanted the Traitors to keep working together.

Episode 8 — Joe Helps Select Abby Lee for Murder

The Traitors shortlisted Abby Lee, Victor and Clyde Moser for their next murder. Joe favored eliminating Abby, who had repeatedly accused Wyatt, and Katie noted that Abby was not targeting the Traitors. Abby’s murder was announced at breakfast, and the cast skipped the usual challenge in favor of a surprise Round Table.

Episode 8 — Joe Votes Out Fellow Traitor Tomica

Victor pressed Joe to name a suspect, and Joe acknowledged that Tomica could be a Traitor. Joe then joined Katie and most of the Faithfuls in voting to banish Tomica, resulting in a 10–2 vote over Victor. Tomica confirmed she was a Traitor. Joe was visibly upset by the outcome in his confessional, but he and Katie stayed in the game as the only active Traitors.

Episode 8 — Confronts Victor in the Kitchen

After Tomica’s elimination, Joe asked Victor whether Victor would target him next. Victor referred to the possibility of being murdered, and Joe responded with a hypothetical remark about murdering Victor if he were a Traitor. This was a tense on-screen exchange, not proof of any later murder choice.

Episode 9 — Joe and Katie Select Morgan for the Poisoned Chalice

After Tomica Adams’ banishment, Joe and Katie were instructed to choose a contestant to receive a poisoned chalice at a celebratory dinner. They selected Morgan Cook rather than Victor Vollbrechthausen; killing Victor so soon after he accused Joe risked drawing more attention to Joe. The players were allowed to trade chalices by mutual agreement before drinking.

Episode 9 — Joe Trades Chalices with Shane; Morgan Is Murdered

Victor tried to convince Joe, Katie and others to exchange glasses because he feared his own chalice was poisoned. They declined. Joe and Shane Beatty made the only successful swap. At the following breakfast, Morgan was missing and confirmed as the Faithful murdered by the poisoned chalice. Joe and Katie remained hidden Traitors.

Episode 9 — Victor and Abbey Question Joe; No Banishment

After breakfast, Victor continued arguing that Joe was a Traitor. Abbey Benjamin questioned Joe’s changing public position on Tomica, while Joe raised Kriste Lewis’ earlier defense of Tomica in a conversation with Jay Vinnedge. The group earned $18,000 in a haunted-cabin mission, where Victor quietly found the Shield. Episode 9 ended without a completed Round Table banishment.

Latest Episode Update: The Poisoned Chalice and Suspicion Around Joe

Episode 9, “Playing Chess,” began after the Faithfuls had exposed Tomica Adams as a Traitor. Joe Vanella and Katie Fites were the two remaining Traitors, and Alan Cumming set them a new murder-in-plain-sight task: choose one of the dinner guests’ chalices to poison. The players could then accept their assigned glass or trade it with someone willing to exchange.

Joe and Katie chose Morgan Cook. Although Victor Vollbrechthausen had made Joe a major suspect after identifying Tomica, the Traitors decided that murdering Victor immediately might make Joe look guilty. Victor was still alarmed at the toast and asked several people to swap chalices. Joe refused Victor’s request, but he and Shane Beatty completed the only exchange. The next morning, Morgan was missing and confirmed as the poisoned-chalice victim.

Joe’s position became more complicated rather than safer. Victor kept pressing him about the earlier Fruitgate evidence, and Abbey Benjamin questioned Joe’s changing attitude toward Tomica before her elimination. Joe also pointed to Kriste Lewis’ previous defense of Tomica while talking with Jay Vinnedge. These were competing suspicions among players, not a completed vote or public revelation of Joe’s role.

The remaining contestants earned $18,000 during the haunted-cabin mission. Victor secretly found the Shield, a fact the players had not been told by episode’s end. There was no Round Table banishment in Episode 9. Joe finished the episode as an active Traitor alongside Katie, with 10 contestants still in the game: eight Faithfuls and two Traitors.

Joe Vanella Quick Facts

Fact Details
Full name Joe Vanella
Age 44 (as reported for the 2026 season)
Hometown Wantagh, New York; grew up in West Hempstead and Rockville Centre
Occupation Funeral director
Professional background Fourth-generation funeral director in a family with a long funeral-service history
Actual game role Original Traitor
Current status Active Traitor after Episode 9
Active Traitor teammate Katie Fites
Former original Traitor teammate Tomica Adams — banished Episode 8
Preseason role preference Traitor
Self-declared superlative Most Likely to Be the Loudest Person in the Room
Episode 9 murder Morgan Cook — poisoned chalice
Episode 9 chalice exchange Joe and Shane Beatty exchanged chalices
Episode 9 banishment None; no completed Round Table banishment
Latest completed episode Episode 9 — “Playing Chess” (November 5, 2026)
Episode 8 vote Tomica Adams
Remaining cast 10: eight Faithfuls and two Traitors

Biography and Background

Joe Vanella is a Long Island funeral director whose professional background spans four generations of his family. Newsday reported that he is 44, grew up in West Hempstead and Rockville Centre, and moved to Wantagh in 2022. He is also a father of three. His family’s history in funeral services is a defining part of his public biography.

Joe has explained that his great-grandfather came to the United States from Italy during Prohibition and opened a funeral parlor in Manhattan. His father later operated funeral homes in Manhattan and Oceanside, and Joe continued in the family profession. His work involves speaking with families during emotionally difficult moments and handling sensitive conversations with composure.

That work history provides context for the role he plays on television. Joe has said that communicating with people under pressure is familiar to him. It does not prove that he can always read other contestants accurately, but it explains why he entered the castle believing those interpersonal skills could be an advantage.

Joe Vanella in the original secondary personal photograph at a baseball stadium
Joe Vanella in the second existing photograph from his published profile.

Education and Career

Joe’s public profile and the sources reviewed for this update focus on his funeral-director career and family background. A specific academic degree or university qualification was not verified in those sources, so this profile does not assign him an education credential that has not been established.

Newsday’s interview is the most useful source for his professional path. Joe described being a fourth-generation funeral director and discussed his father’s funeral homes as well as his great-grandfather’s arrival from Italy. Those details support his career history without requiring assumptions about a particular business title or ownership arrangement today.

Professional Achievements and Notable Work

Joe’s principal documented professional distinction is continuing his family’s funeral-service career into a fourth generation. His experience working with grieving families and navigating emotionally charged conversations is the aspect of his job he highlighted when discussing his casting on The Traitors: New Blood.

In his preseason comments, Joe described himself as comfortable talking to people and observing how they respond in different situations. He intended to draw on that experience in the game, where information often comes from conversations rather than direct evidence.

Pre-Show Strategy

Before the season, Joe said he wanted to be noticed without becoming an obvious target. He described himself as one of the louder personalities in a group, but he did not want to be so quiet that people wondered what he was hiding. His plan was to befriend everyone, whether that person ultimately proved to be a Traitor or a Faithful, and to pay attention to how people reacted during conversations.

Joe also discussed observing contestants over time rather than judging a single moment in isolation. This was his stated plan before the game began; it should be distinguished from what the episodes actually show him doing.

Why Joe Wanted to Be a Traitor

Joe entered the game hoping to receive the Traitor role. He believed his comfort in conversation, familiarity with emotional situations and willingness to call people out could help him handle the social demands of the competition. Alan Cumming selected Joe and Tomica Adams as the original Traitors, making his preferred role his actual assignment from the beginning.

The role gave Joe control over private murder discussions while allowing him to participate in the same public conversations as the Faithfuls. His professional background was part of the strategy he expected to use, but the game has also exposed the risks of that role: one convincing theory about his actions could rapidly change his position.

Joe’s Current Traitor Strategy

Joe’s strategy has relied on building relationships while keeping his decisions as a Traitor separate from his public behavior. Early in the season, that included selecting Kim Daily as the first murder victim, choosing Katie over Xavier for the third Traitor position and joining Tomica and Katie in selecting Logan Smith after Arisa Thomas was banished.

Episode 5 introduced a new test: the Traitors had to get a Faithful to catch a cursed apple in plain sight. Joe’s first attempt against Morgan failed, and he ate the apple to avoid making the failed pass even more suspicious. In Episode 6, he succeeded in passing an apple to Niyyah, who caught it and was murdered. The task was successful, but Victor’s interpretation of the fruit sequence created an ongoing threat.

In Episode 7, Joe and Katie resisted Tomica’s request to murder Victor because doing so could make Victor’s allegations appear credible. The group instead murdered Mark. In Episode 8, Joe tried to prevent further internal friction and supported murdering Abby because she had drawn attention toward Wyatt. Yet the surprise Round Table brought the pressure back to Tomica. Joe conceded that she could be a Traitor, then joined the vote that eliminated her.

After losing Tomica in Episode 8, Joe and Katie worked as a two-person Traitor team. In Episode 9 they poisoned Morgan rather than Victor, reasoning that a murder of Joe’s outspoken accuser could make Joe appear responsible. Their decision succeeded in eliminating a Faithful, but Victor continued investigating Joe and Abbey also questioned his changes of position around Tomica. With no banishment in Episode 9, Joe is still active, but that suspicion remains unresolved.

During the poisoned-chalice toast, Victor’s request to trade with Joe was rejected, while Joe did exchange glasses with Shane. Joe also highlighted Kriste’s earlier defense of Tomica during a discussion with Jay. These were documented Episode 9 interactions; they do not establish that Joe persuaded the Faithfuls to vote for any particular person.

Strengths

  • Comfort in social situations: Joe has described talking with people as a strength of his work and personality, and his preseason plan was to build relationships across the castle.
  • Composure around emotional conversations: His funeral-director career regularly places him in sensitive situations, which he identified as relevant experience for the show.
  • Ability to operate in public and private roles: Joe remains in the competition after nine aired episodes despite helping make major Traitor decisions, including the poisoned-chalice murder of Morgan Cook.
  • Successful execution of the apple murder: After his first attempt against Morgan failed, he completed the required pass to Niyyah.
  • Adaptability at the Round Table: In Episode 8, Joe voted out his fellow Traitor Tomica rather than hold a public position increasingly difficult to defend. This kept Joe active, though it also cost him an ally.

Potential Weaknesses and Exposure Risks

Joe’s most visible risk is Victor’s Fruitgate theory. Victor connected Joe’s handling of the cursed apple to Tomica’s fruit offers, and Tomica’s Episode 8 reveal lent weight to his suspicions. Victor again accused Joe during Episode 9; the accusation did not yet lead to a completed banishment vote.

Episode 9 added another point of scrutiny. Abbey Benjamin questioned Joe’s changing public position on Tomica, while Joe and Katie chose not to murder Victor for fear of drawing further attention to Joe. After the episode aired, Morgan said in a Decider exit interview that she had been preparing to accuse Joe at the next Round Table. That interview is Morgan’s retrospective account, not a speech actually made on screen.

Joe still has Katie as his Traitor partner but no longer has Tomica. His earlier close relationship with Michael Foote is historical, not an active alliance. Other players also discussed Kriste, Wyatt and Victor, so suspicion was not unanimous; Episode 9 ended with Joe’s role still hidden from the Faithfuls.

Personality and Social Style

In his Newsday interview, Joe described himself as one of the louder people in a group and said he wanted to be noticeable without inviting suspicion. He also framed his Long Island identity as part of his willingness to call people out when he believed something was wrong. These are his own descriptions, not independent proof of his ability to detect deception.

His approach combines sociability with observation, but the audience has now seen a contradiction between Joe’s attempts to appear helpful and the murders he helps plan privately. By Episode 9, he had reached the final 10 while facing open questions from Victor and Abbey about his behavior. Those suspicions are part of the on-screen game and do not amount to a completed banishment.

Current Role & Status

Fact Details
Role Traitor — selected in Episode 1
Status Active after Episode 9
Active Traitor teammate Katie Fites
Former Traitor teammate Tomica Adams — banished as Traitor in Episode 8
Most recent confirmed murder Morgan Cook, Episode 9 — poisoned chalice chosen by Joe and Katie
Most recent confirmed banishment Tomica Adams, Episode 8 (Traitor; 10–2 vote)
Joe’s Episode 8 vote Tomica Adams
Major current suspicion Victor continues accusing Joe; Abbey questions his changing position on Tomica
Episode 8 closing exchange Joe and Victor confronted each other after Tomica’s exit; Victor continued questioning Joe in Episode 9
Episode 9 chalice exchange Joe and Shane Beatty exchanged glasses; Morgan was the murder victim
Episode 9 banishment No completed Round Table vote
Contestants still in game 10 — eight Faithfuls, two Traitors

Relationships, Alliances and Suspicions

Joe and Tomica Adams

Tomica was Joe’s fellow original Traitor. They selected Kim Daily as the first murder victim, evaluated Katie and Xavier for the third Traitor position, chose Katie, and later joined her in deciding to murder Logan. In Episode 6, Victor’s Fruitgate theory implicated both original Traitors. Their working relationship became more difficult as Tomica and Katie argued and the suspicion around Tomica increased. In Episode 8, Joe voted to banish Tomica and then spoke emotionally about losing his teammate. Tomica is no longer an active ally.

Joe and Katie Fites

Katie joined Joe and Tomica after the Accomplice challenge. She and Joe resisted Tomica’s request to murder Victor in Episode 7 and voted to banish Tomica in Episode 8. As the two remaining Traitors in Episode 9, Joe and Katie selected Morgan Cook for the poisoned-chalice murder, avoiding Victor because his immediate elimination could have implicated Joe. No new recruitment or banishment was confirmed in Episode 9.

Joe and Victor Vollbrechthausen

Victor remains Joe’s clearest public accuser. His Fruitgate theory linked Joe’s handling of an apple to Tomica’s behavior, and the Episode 8 banishment confirmed Tomica was a Traitor. Victor then asked Joe to trade chalices in Episode 9, but Joe declined. Victor continued challenging Joe, who remained unbanished at the end of the episode.

Joe and Abby Lee

Abby had repeatedly argued that Wyatt Gillespie was a Traitor. In Episode 8, Joe argued in the turret that she had generated significant dissent, and the Traitor team murdered her. Abby’s mistaken focus on Wyatt provides context for their decision; the choice did not prevent Tomica’s banishment at the next Round Table.

Joe and Niyyah Hayes

Niyyah became Joe’s murder-in-plain-sight victim in Episode 6 after she caught the apple he passed. While they were in staged coffins, Joe told her he was sorry and had sacrificed a Faithful. The episode then confirmed Niyyah’s murder. This was an in-game action, not a public reveal of Joe’s identity.

Joe and Michael Foote

Joe and Michael developed a close relationship during the early episodes, with Michael treating Joe as a trusted connection. Michael was banished in Episode 6 after receiving eight votes and was revealed as a Faithful. Joe voted for Wyatt, not Michael. Their relationship is now part of Joe’s historical game record rather than an active alliance.

Joe and Morgan Cook

In Episode 5, Joe tried to pass Morgan the cursed apple, but she did not catch it. In Episode 9, Joe and Katie selected Morgan as their poisoned-chalice target. She did not survive the toast and was confirmed murdered at breakfast. Morgan later said in a November 6 Decider exit interview that she had planned to accuse Joe at the next Round Table; that claim describes her unrealized plan, not an Episode 9 vote.

Joe and Abbey Benjamin

During Episode 9, Abbey raised doubts about Joe’s shifting defense of Tomica before her banishment. Her comments show another source of suspicion in the Faithful group, but she did not vote to eliminate Joe in the episode because no completed Round Table took place.

Joe and Kim Daily

Kim was the first person murdered by Joe and Tomica. Following her elimination, Kim said in post-game coverage that she had started to wonder about Joe before her murder, but the suspicion had not developed into a supported public case.

Joe and Logan Smith

Joe joined Tomica and Katie in choosing Logan as the murder victim after Arisa Thomas was banished. Logan’s attention to Xavier’s earlier doubts about Katie made him a potential risk to the newly expanded Traitor team.

Social Media

Joe’s public Instagram is @thejoevanella. The account is identified as his in the Marie Claire cast guide and in Cosmopolitan’s contestant tracker. As with all cast social accounts, posts made after filming should not be confused with confirmed in-game developments.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Joe Vanella a Traitor or a Faithful?

Joe is an original Traitor. Alan Cumming selected him alongside Tomica Adams in Episode 1; Katie Fites later joined the Traitor team.

Is Joe Vanella still in The Traitors: New Blood after Episode 9?

Yes. Joe remains an active Traitor after Episode 9 on November 5, 2026. He and Katie Fites are the two Traitors still competing among 10 contestants.

Who are the remaining Traitors after Episode 9?

Joe Vanella and Katie Fites remain the two active Traitors. Tomica Adams was banished in Episode 8, and no new Traitor reveal or recruitment was shown in Episode 9.

Did Joe vote for Tomica Adams in Episode 8?

Yes. Joe and Katie both joined the 10–2 vote to banish their fellow Traitor Tomica. Joe later became emotional about her departure.

Who did Joe and the other Traitors murder in Episode 8?

Abby Lee was murdered in Episode 8. Joe supported the choice because Abby had repeatedly raised suspicions about Wyatt Gillespie.

What happened between Joe and Victor at the end of Episode 8?

Joe and Victor confronted each other after Tomica’s exit. During Episode 9, Victor tried to exchange his chalice with Joe, who declined, and continued accusing Joe after Morgan’s murder.

What happened to Joe Vanella in Episode 9?

Joe and Katie Fites selected Morgan Cook for the poisoned-chalice murder. Joe exchanged glasses with Shane Beatty, survived the toast and continued facing suspicion from Victor and Abbey. No one was banished in Episode 9.

Who did Joe and Katie murder in Episode 9?

They targeted Morgan Cook with the poisoned chalice. Morgan was absent from the next breakfast and confirmed murdered as a Faithful.

Why did Joe and Katie choose Morgan instead of Victor?

Episode 9 coverage explains that killing Victor immediately after he accused Joe might have made Joe look more suspicious. The Traitors chose Morgan instead.

Did Joe trade chalices with Shane Beatty?

Yes. Joe and Shane made the only successful glass exchange during the deadly toast. Victor tried unsuccessfully to exchange his cup with Joe and other contestants.

Was Joe banished in Episode 9?

No. Episode 9 ended without a completed Round Table banishment vote. Joe remained in the game alongside Katie.

Did Morgan Cook suspect Joe before her murder?

In a post-elimination interview published November 6, Morgan said she had planned a six-point case against Joe for the next Round Table. She was murdered before she could deliver that planned speech.

Who did Joe murder in Episode 6?

Joe successfully performed the murder-in-plain-sight apple pass to Niyyah Hayes, who caught the apple and was later confirmed as murdered.

What is Fruitgate, and why does it put Joe at risk?

Fruitgate is Victor Vollbrechthausen’s theory linking Joe’s handling of a poisoned apple and Tomica’s fruit offers to Niyyah’s murder. Victor was correct that Joe and Tomica were both Traitors; Tomica’s role was publicly revealed in Episode 8.

What does Joe Vanella do for a living?

Joe is a fourth-generation funeral director from Long Island, New York. Newsday reported he lived in Wantagh during the 2026 season.

How old is Joe Vanella?

Joe was 44 in a September 2026 Newsday interview and the season’s published cast coverage.

Who did Joe vote for in Episode 6?

Joe voted for Wyatt Gillespie. Michael Foote was banished with eight votes and revealed to be a Faithful.

Sources

Hollywood Outbreak: November 5 Episode 9 recap documenting Joe and Katie’s poisoned-chalice assignment, Morgan’s death, the sole Joe/Shane glass exchange, haunted-cabin mission and Victor’s Shield: Episode 9 recap.

The A.V. Club (Episode 9): Reporting on Joe’s conversation with Jay about Kriste’s defense of Tomica, the continued Victor/Joe confrontation, chalice twist and absence of a completed banishment: Episode 9 coverage.

Metro Weekly (Episode 9): November 5 account of Joe and Katie selecting a poisoned chalice, the unsuccessful Victor swap attempts and Morgan’s murder: Episode 9 recap.

Decider (Episode 9 results): Explains why Joe and Katie avoided targeting Victor and confirms Morgan as the poisoned-chalice murder victim: Episode 9 elimination report.

Decider (Morgan Cook interview): Morgan’s November 6 post-elimination statements that she suspected Joe and had planned—but did not deliver—a Round Table accusation: Morgan Cook exit interview.

TV Grapevine: Episode 9 recap confirming Joe and Shane’s chalice exchange, the $18,000 mission, Victor’s secret Shield and the unresolved banishment: Episode 9 recap.

Newsday: Joe’s age, Wantagh residence, family background, fourth-generation funeral-director career, and preseason comments about being noticeable while building trust: Newsday.

Entertainment Weekly: Original civilian cast announcement, Joe’s age, occupation, self-declared superlative and preseason strategy interview: Entertainment Weekly.

Marie Claire: Cast guide listing Joe’s public Instagram handle, age and occupation: Marie Claire.

TVLine: Episode 3–4 coverage of the Accomplice challenge, selection of Katie over Xavier, and early Traitor game decisions: TVLine.

TheWrap: Episode 5 account of the murder-in-plain-sight apple task and Joe’s description of its rules: TheWrap.

The A.V. Club (Episode 5): Recap supporting the Episode 5 vote and Joe’s unsuccessful apple pass to Morgan Cook: The A.V. Club (Episode 5).

Reality Blurred: Episode 6 recap documenting Niyyah’s murder, Joe’s remark in the staged coffin, Victor’s Fruitgate allegations, and the failed Round Table attempt to act on them: Reality Blurred.

Vulture: Independent Episode 6 coverage of Niyyah’s murder, Victor’s theory and Michael Foote’s banishment: Vulture.

Decider: Episode 6 elimination results documenting Niyyah and Michael’s exits: Decider.

DIRECTV Insider: Episode 7 turret decisions, Mark’s murder, the scarecrow mission and the Round Table interrupted by the Power of the Pardon: DIRECTV Insider.

Metro Weekly: Episode 7 reporting on Fruitgate, Joe and Tomica’s relationship at the Round Table, and the unresolved pardon twist: Metro Weekly.

TODAY (via AOL): Detailed Episode 8 coverage of Joe’s efforts to hold the Traitor team together, the Abby Lee murder decision, vote against Tomica, his reaction and the kitchen exchange with Victor: TODAY (via AOL).

TV Insider: Episode 7–8 elimination tally confirming Shane’s pardon of Victor, Abby Lee’s murder, Tomica’s banishment and remaining Traitor count: TV Insider.

TraitorsNewBlood.digital original profile: Existing Joe biography, two photograph URLs, historical timeline, internal links and the established article style used as continuity references: TraitorsNewBlood.digital original profile.

Last updated: November 7, 2026. This article is intended to be updated as new episodes reveal changes to Joe Vanella’s role, alliances, suspicions, challenge performance or elimination status.

BEHIND EVERY SMILE, A STRATEGY

Know the players.
Follow the game.

View the live cast list