Abbey Benjamin is a 37-year-old nurse from Mangham, Louisiana, and one of the 22 original civilian contestants on NBC's The Traitors: New Blood. Before entering the castle, she described a people-first approach: stay genuine, build trust, and get to know both potential allies and opponents rather than adopt a different on-camera personality.
Abbey remains an active Faithful after Episode 9, with 10 players left: eight Faithfuls and two Traitors. Following her successful Episode 8 vote against Tomica Adams, Abbey questioned Joe Vanella’s shifting position on Tomica during Episode 9, contributed to the haunted-cabin mission, and survived the poisoned-chalice murder that eliminated Morgan Cook. No Round Table banishment was completed in the latest episode.
Live Game Status
Current role: Faithful. Current status: Still competing after Episode 9.
Latest completed episode: Episode 9 — “Playing Chess” (November 5, 2026).
Episode 8: Abbey voted for Tomica Adams, who was banished by a 10–2 vote and revealed as a Traitor.
Episode 9: Abbey survived the poisoned-chalice murder that eliminated Morgan Cook, questioned Joe Vanella’s changing defense of Tomica, and recovered a necklace during the haunted-cabin mission. The group earned $18,000; no completed Round Table banishment occurred.
Game balance: 10 contestants remain — eight Faithfuls, including Abbey, and two Traitors known to viewers: Joe Vanella and Katie Fites.
Spoiler warning: This profile contains confirmed spoilers through Episode 9, including Abbey’s earlier Round Table votes, Tomica Adams’ Traitor reveal, Morgan Cook’s poisoned-chalice murder, Abbey’s haunted-cabin challenge contribution and the unresolved suspicions around Joe Vanella and Victor Vollbrechthausen.
Episode-by-Episode Timeline
Episode 1 — Enters the Castle as a Faithful
Abbey joined the original 22-player competition as a Faithful. Her preseason plan was to stay authentic, make connections and win trust. She did not enter with a public intention to play the confrontational investigator.
Episode 2 — Votes for Madeline and Survives
After Kim Daily was murdered, Abbey voted to banish Madeline Kostopulos. Madeline was eliminated and revealed as a Faithful. Abbey remained in the game.
Episode 3 — Survives as Katie Joins the Traitors
Xavier Scruggs was murdered and Katie Fites joined Joe Vanella and Tomica Adams as the third Traitor. Abbey remained a Faithful. Available episode reporting does not identify a separate Abbey-led accusation or challenge win in this episode.
Episode 4 — Votes for Arisa; the Field Narrows
Abbey voted for Arisa Thomas, who was banished and revealed as a Faithful. Logan Smith was later confirmed murdered. Abbey continued in the competition. Her individual challenge actions are not established in the reporting reviewed.
Episode 5 — Votes to Banish Sherry Kuehl
Abbey joined the majority against Sherry Kuehl in the Episode 5 Round Table. Sherry was banished with 11 votes and revealed as a Faithful. The episode also introduced a murder-in-plain-sight twist that continued into the next episode. The vote is documented; the sources do not establish Abbey as the person who originated the accusations against Sherry.
Episode 6 — Votes for Michael Foote After the Apple Murder
The Traitors' cursed-apple murder was revealed to have claimed Niyyah Hayes. Victor argued that the fruit exchange implicated Joe and Tomica, but the group banished Michael Foote instead. Abbey voted for Michael. Michael was revealed as a Faithful, and Abbey advanced again.
Episode 7 — Votes for Victor as the Pardon Cliffhanger Unfolds
Mark Zgoda was murdered. In the scarecrow challenge, Shane won the hidden Power of the Pardon, though the group did not learn who held it immediately. Abbey voted to banish Victor Vollbrechthausen, one of the five votes he received. Before Victor could exit and reveal his role, Alan Cumming suspended the result pending the pardon decision. Abbey remained in the field of 13 players after the cliffhanger.
Episode 8 — Votes for Tomica; a Traitor Is Exposed
Shane revealed that he held the Power of the Pardon and chose to save Victor. Abby Lee was murdered. At the next Round Table, Abbey voted for Tomica Adams, joining the 10-vote majority against her; Tomica and Jay Vinnedge voted for Victor instead. Tomica revealed she was a Traitor. Abbey survived into the final 11, alongside eight other Faithfuls and two Traitors.
Episode 9 — Questions Joe and Recovers the Necklace
After Tomica’s banishment, Abbey was among the remaining players at a celebratory Highland feast. She spoke about the personal significance of having this opportunity after caring for her family, and Kriste Lewis offered encouragement. Alan Cumming then announced the poisoned-chalice challenge; only Joe Vanella and Shane Beatty exchanged drinks. At breakfast, Morgan Cook was revealed as the Traitors’ murder victim.
Abbey questioned Joe’s changed approach to Tomica before her exit and raised questions about his refusal to trade a cup with Victor. She had not ruled out Victor as a suspect, however. At the haunted cabin, Abbey retrieved the final requested necklace from a murky toilet, helping the group secure its second correct item and $18,000 in total mission winnings. Victor secretly discovered a Shield. The episode ended without a completed Round Table banishment, leaving Abbey still in the game.
Latest Episode Update — Episode 9: Suspicions and the Haunted Cabin
Episode 9, “Playing Chess,” gave Abbey Benjamin a more visible role in the castle. After the Faithfuls exposed Tomica Adams as a Traitor, Joe Vanella and Katie Fites selected Morgan Cook as the target of their poisoned-chalice murder. Players were allowed to trade cups, but the only exchange was between Joe and Shane Beatty. The next morning Morgan was absent, confirming her elimination. Abbey remained one of the eight active Faithfuls.
Abbey began questioning Joe’s shifting explanations about Tomica: she noted that he had defended Tomica earlier but became willing to name her when banishment looked possible. Abbey also questioned the chalice exchange and Joe’s refusal to swap with Victor. At the same time, she still had doubts about Victor, so her comments should not be presented as proof she had solved Joe’s role.
The haunted-cabin challenge provided Abbey’s clearest individual contribution of the episode. She recovered a spirit’s necklace from a foul-looking toilet in the final round, helping the contestants bank $18,000 from two successful items. Victor separately found a secret Shield. The episode ended before a Round Table vote, so Abbey had no new documented banishment ballot and remained active as one of 10 contestants.
Abbey Benjamin Quick Facts
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Full name | Abbey Benjamin |
| Age in 2026 cast materials | 37 |
| Hometown | Mangham, Louisiana |
| Main profession | Nurse |
| Other work | Dance teacher and children's book author |
| Show | The Traitors: New Blood |
| Role | Faithful |
| Current status | Active after Episode 9 (November 5, 2026) |
| Latest completed episode | Episode 9 — Playing Chess |
| Contestants remaining | 10 (eight Faithfuls; two Traitors) |
| Self-declared superlative | Most Likely to Be Smiling 24/7 |
Who Is Abbey Benjamin?
Abbey Benjamin is a nurse from Mangham, Louisiana, who joined The Traitors: New Blood as part of the show's first all-civilian U.S. cast. Her cast interviews emphasized her enjoyment of meeting people, building connections and earning trust, qualities that also informed her stated plan for navigating the competition.
Official cast coverage identifies Abbey with the playful superlative “Most Likely to Be Smiling 24/7.” The comment reflects the friendly personality she presented before the season; it should not be mistaken for evidence about her private gameplay choices.
Abbey Benjamin's Nursing Career
Abbey's principal listed occupation is nursing. In preseason interview material, she described the value of making decisions with incomplete information and suggested that the experience could be relevant to playing as a Faithful. It would go beyond the evidence, however, to argue that nursing itself proves she can detect deception.
Abbey Benjamin's Career Beyond Nursing
Her professional background also includes dance teaching and self-published children's writing. Public posts associated with Benjamin Books discuss inclusion, disability awareness and learning through children's stories.
Titles referenced in her existing published profile include In My Sissy's Wheelchair, When You See a Child Who's Different, A Mother's Love and Dance from the Heart. These are retained as previously published professional details, not presented as new Episode 8 revelations.
Abbey Benjamin's Game Plan Before The Traitors
Abbey's pre-show strategy was explicitly relationship-based. In her cast interview, she said she wanted to be herself and earn trust among both the Traitors and the Faithfuls so she could make it as far as possible. That was a plan stated before the competition, rather than proof of a specific alliance or manipulation inside the castle.
Why Abbey Wanted to Be a Faithful
Abbey preferred the Faithful role before filming, describing it as a fit for her way of handling uncertainty and people. She also described the show as a personal challenge she wanted to pursue after spending years prioritizing family responsibilities. On the show, she was indeed assigned the Faithful role.
Abbey Benjamin's Current Game Strategy
Abbey entered the game with a trust-building plan, but her recorded votes and Episode 9 comments provide a clearer view of her developing approach. She backed the banishments of Sherry Kuehl and Michael Foote, voted for Victor Vollbrechthausen in Episode 7, then helped eliminate Tomica Adams in Episode 8. Those earlier ballots remain part of her history.
In Episode 9, Abbey questioned why Joe Vanella had defended Tomica earlier and then changed his position as votes turned against her. She also questioned Joe’s reluctance to trade chalices with Victor. These observations place Joe among her possible suspects, but coverage also shows that she continued to consider Victor suspicious. She did not cast a new Round Table vote in Episode 9, which ended before banishment.
Abbey Benjamin and the Social Game
Abbey’s relationship-focused preseason strategy remains relevant, but Episode 9 added more than survival. At the Highland feast she spoke about how meaningful the opportunity was after years spent caring for her family, and fellow Faithful Kriste Lewis encouraged her. That scene illustrated a social connection, not a confirmed secret alliance.
Later, Abbey was willing to question Joe’s behavior toward Tomica while still evaluating Victor as a possible Traitor. The distinction matters: the public edit documents a developing suspicion, not a final accusation, coordinated voting bloc or established allegiance.
Abbey Benjamin's Strengths
- Relationship focus: Her stated approach emphasizes trust and getting to know people.
- Adaptation: She remained in the competition through multiple elimination rounds and changing vote outcomes.
- Composure under uncertainty: Abbey herself has connected her nursing background with making decisions without complete information.
- Approachable presentation: Her official superlative and interviews emphasize positivity and authenticity.
- Challenge participation: In Episode 9 she retrieved the final necklace in the haunted-cabin mission, helping the group earn $18,000.
Potential Challenges for Abbey
Abbey’s earlier votes against Sherry and Michael, both Faithfuls, and against Victor before his pardon show the difficulty of judging suspects with incomplete evidence. Her Episode 8 vote for Tomica was correct, but Tomica’s reveal did not automatically identify the two remaining Traitors.
Episode 9 adds a new uncertainty: Abbey has questioned Joe’s change of position around Tomica while still considering Victor suspicious. With no Round Table banishment in that episode, those competing theories were unresolved at the cutoff.
Abbey Benjamin's Personality
In pre-show materials Abbey presented herself as enthusiastic about people and unwilling to manufacture a new television persona. Her “Smiling 24/7” cast superlative is consistent with that public presentation, but the show does not provide a complete record of how she thinks or feels about every fellow contestant.
Abbey's Most Traitorous Real-Life Story
In a pre-season Entertainment Weekly cast feature, Abbey recalled secretly taking her sister's car for a night while she was a teenager and returning it without telling her. The anecdote appeared in her published profile before these episode updates and is retained here as biographical background, not as evidence of gameplay deception.
Current Role & Status
| Game detail | Verified status after Episode 9 |
|---|---|
| Role | Faithful |
| Elimination status | Active — not murdered or banished |
| Episodes completed | 9 |
| Remaining contestants | 10 (8 Faithfuls, 2 Traitors) |
| Episode 5 vote | Sherry Kuehl — banished, Faithful |
| Episode 6 vote | Michael Foote — banished, Faithful |
| Episode 7 vote | Victor Vollbrechthausen — pardoned by Shane in Episode 8 |
| Episode 8 vote | Tomica Adams — banished, Traitor |
| Episode 9 outcome | Morgan Cook murdered; no Round Table banishment vote |
| Episode 9 challenge | Recovered the final necklace in the haunted-cabin mission; group earned $18,000 |
| Current suspicions | Questioned Joe’s changing position on Tomica; also considered Victor suspicious |
| Remaining Traitors (known to viewers) | Joe Vanella and Katie Fites |
Relationships, Alliances & Suspicions
Joe Vanella: In Episode 9 Abbey questioned how Joe shifted from defending Tomica to allowing that she might be a Traitor. She also questioned Joe’s refusal to trade chalices with Victor. Joe is a Traitor known to viewers, but Abbey had not exposed him through a completed vote.
Victor Vollbrechthausen: Abbey voted against Victor in Episode 7, before Shane saved him with the Power of the Pardon. In Episode 9 she still considered Victor potentially suspicious, even while reasoning that his murder could implicate Joe. Victor’s secret Shield find was not publicly announced to the players.
Kriste Lewis: At the Episode 9 feast, Kriste encouraged Abbey as they spoke about motherhood and Abbey’s opportunity to do something for herself. This establishes a supportive interaction, not a formal gameplay alliance.
Tomica Adams: Abbey voted to banish Tomica in Episode 8. Tomica was revealed as a Traitor, and Joe’s changing position toward her became an Abbey-specific line of questioning in Episode 9.
Sherry Kuehl and Michael Foote: Abbey voted against both earlier in the season; both were revealed as Faithfuls.
Katie Fites: Katie and Joe are the two Traitors known to viewers after Episode 9. Abbey’s confirmed Episode 9 comments focused on Joe and Victor; a new specific accusation against Katie by Abbey is not established by the sources reviewed.
Alliances: No independently verified source establishes a formal Abbey-led or exclusive alliance through Episode 9.
Abbey Benjamin on Social Media
Instagram: @abbeybenj — public account identified by the cast coverage and her previously published profile.
Related Traitors: New Blood Profiles
Abbey Benjamin FAQ
Is Abbey Benjamin a Traitor or a Faithful?
Abbey Benjamin is a Faithful. Her role is unchanged through Episode 9.
Is Abbey Benjamin still in the game after Episode 9?
Yes. Abbey is one of eight Faithfuls among 10 players remaining after Episode 9.
How old is Abbey Benjamin?
Her 2026 cast biographies list her as 37 years old.
Where is Abbey Benjamin from?
Abbey is from Mangham, Louisiana.
What does Abbey Benjamin do?
Abbey is a nurse. Her professional background also includes dance teaching and children's books.
Who did Abbey Benjamin vote for in Episode 5?
Abbey voted to banish Sherry Kuehl. Sherry left the game and revealed that she was a Faithful.
Who did Abbey Benjamin vote for in Episode 6?
Abbey voted for Michael Foote, who was banished and revealed as a Faithful.
Did Abbey vote to banish Victor in Episode 7?
Yes. She was one of five contestants voting for Victor. Shane Beatty used the Power of the Pardon in Episode 8, keeping Victor in the game.
Who did Abbey Benjamin vote for in Episode 8?
Abbey voted for Tomica Adams. Tomica was banished 10–2 and revealed to be a Traitor.
Did Abbey Benjamin win the Power of the Pardon?
No. Shane Beatty won the power in Episode 7 and used it to save Victor in Episode 8.
Which Traitors remain after Episode 9?
Joe Vanella and Katie Fites are the two remaining Traitors known to viewers after Episode 9.
What was Abbey Benjamin’s preseason strategy?
Abbey said she planned to be herself, gain trust and build relationships with both Faithfuls and potential Traitors.
What happened in the latest episode?
In Episode 9, Morgan Cook was murdered by the poisoned chalice. Abbey questioned Joe Vanella’s shifting position on Tomica Adams and recovered a necklace during the haunted-cabin mission. No Round Table banishment was completed.
Did Abbey Benjamin survive the poisoned chalice in Episode 9?
Yes. Abbey survived the toast; Morgan Cook was the Faithful murdered by the poisoned chalice.
Who does Abbey Benjamin suspect after Episode 9?
Abbey questioned Joe Vanella’s changing stance toward Tomica Adams and his behavior at the toast. Episode coverage also shows that she still considered Victor Vollbrechthausen suspicious. No Episode 9 banishment vote was held.
What did Abbey Benjamin do in the haunted-cabin challenge?
Abbey recovered the final spirit’s necklace from a murky toilet, helping the group earn a total of $18,000 for two correct items.
Was anyone banished in Episode 9?
No. The episode ended without a completed Round Table vote. Morgan Cook was the only player eliminated during Episode 9.
Sources
TraitorsNewBlood.digital: Abbey's pre-existing profile, used to retain her biography, nursing and writing background, cast image reference, earlier timeline, Instagram and established structure: Original Abbey Benjamin profile.
Marie Claire: Abbey's reported age, Mangham hometown, nursing occupation, confirmed Faithful role, public Instagram and relationship-first preseason plan: Cast and Instagram guide.
TV Insider: Official cast interview material including Abbey's personality, ‘Smiling 24/7’ superlative and approach to authenticity: Cast interview gallery.
NBCUniversal: Official confirmation of the series' all-civilian premise and original cast context: Program and cast announcement.
LinkedIn: Public information on Abbey's children's books, Benjamin Books and writing related to inclusion and disability awareness: Public Benjamin Books post.
Entertainment Weekly: Abbey's pre-show anecdote about borrowing her sister's car without permission, retained from her original profile: Preseason cast feature.
OpenThread News cast tracker: Published contestant-by-contestant ballots for Episodes 5, 6 and 8, used to document Abbey's recorded votes without attributing invented motives: Episode voting record.
OpenThread News — Episode 7: Round Table voting breakdown identifying Abbey as one of five players who voted for Victor, alongside Mark's murder and the Pardon cliffhanger: Episode 7 vote recap.
OpenThread News — Episode 8: Abbey's Episode 8 vote for Tomica, the 10–2 elimination tally and the confirmed 11-player cast balance: Episode 8 vote recap.
TV Insider: Episode-by-episode elimination totals, Victor's postponed Episode 7 banishment, Shane's pardon, Abby Lee's murder and Tomica's Traitor reveal: Elimination results and Episode 8 update.
The A.V. Club: Independent Episode 8 recap of the Round Table debate and the majority vote that exposed Tomica, without attributing unreported remarks to Abbey: Episode 8 recap.
The A.V. Club — Episode 9: Abbey’s comments about Joe’s changing defense of Tomica, her continuing uncertainty about Victor, and her personal remarks at the feast; also confirms Morgan’s poisoned-chalice murder: Episode 9 recap.
Metro Weekly — Episode 9: Abbey’s conversation with Kriste Lewis, questions about Joe, and the haunted-cabin mission in which she retrieved the final necklace to help the group bank $18,000: Episode 9 mission and gameplay recap.
TODAY.com (via AOL) — Episode 9: Episode coverage documenting Abbey’s question about Joe refusing to swap his chalice with Victor, Morgan’s murder, Abbey’s final-item retrieval in the haunted-cabin mission and the unresolved Round Table: Episode 9 recap.
OpenThread News — Episode 9: Episode summary confirming the 10-player field, two active Traitors, Morgan’s murder, Abbey’s final-item retrieval, and absence of a completed Round Table banishment: Episode 9 results recap.
Last updated: November 8, 2026. This article is intended to be updated as new episodes reveal changes to Abbey Benjamin’s role, alliances, suspicions, challenge performance or elimination status.